Combine all ingredients in a small bowl and mix well. If you are using canned tuna packed in water, drain it and add in 1 tablespoon of good quality extra virgin olive oil. So glad I tried it, because it’s delicious. I think this has changed how I eat canned tuna forever. We’re so glad you made this with the cottage cheese and liked it. Cottage cheese. To make the best tuna salad sandwich, it helps to start with high quality canned tuna. We love Tuna recipes and this Tuna Mornay, Tuna Melt Casserole, and Open Faced Tuna Melt are some of our favorites! The trick to a top-notch tuna salad recipe is the inclusion of both crunch and zest. I’ll never understand. Or store in an … Or, if you don't like the oil the tuna is packed in, you can drain it, and add back in 2 teaspoons of your favorite extra virgin olive oil. Yay! Now that you know how to make tuna salad, you’re well on your way to more sandwich success. Did you know you can save this recipe and order the ingredients for. Or, for a sweeter flavor, use chopped bread and butter pickles or sweet relish in the filling. It's all in the combination of ingredients—the best tuna you can find, cottage cheese and mayo, and good use of fresh dill, parsley, and more. Hi Corey, I usually use small curd cottage cheese, but large curd will work if that’s what you have. We prefer tuna that is packed in extra virgin olive oil, because the oil intensifies the flavor of the tuna. For many people, those days when you had a tuna salad sandwich for lunch are still some of the happiest childhood memories. My mom has been bugging me to make more! For many people, those days when you had a tuna salad sandwich for lunch are still some of the happiest childhood memories. Hello! I know I sound like a picky perfectionist (well…), but I just don’t get putting stuff in there that essentially covers up the taste of a great tuna sandwich. Chop onion, celery, and pickle into very small pieces& add to bowl. With just a little chopping and about 15 minutes of effort, you can create delicious tuna salad sandwiches hearty enough to feed a hungry family of four. Mix all ingredients to combine, breaking up any large chunks of tuna fish … This recipe has become my go-to recipe for tuna salad. Make tuna salad special with this great sub sandwich from Carole Lanthier of Courtice, Ontario.... Crunchy Tuna Sandwiches. To stretch the tuna further, add an extra hard-boiled egg. They can be used interchangeably so you decide which you prefer. Tuna salad is one of those quick and easy sandwich recipes to make, and it can be served on bread, toast, lettuce leaves, as a wrap or simply with a handful of crackers. Finding the best canned tuna for your taste may require a bit of experimentation with brands. The only thing I change is that I use lime juice instead of lemon, simply due to personal preference. Mayonnaise or Greek Yogurt – You’ll need mayonnaise or Greek Yogurt to help bind your tuna salad together. I’m going to try your recipe tonight, but will add one thing: A big honkin’ hunk of Cheddar Cheese on each sandwich! This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners; your purchases via these links can benefit Simply Recipes. They are both thick, creamy dressings that contain vegetable oil, lemon juice or vinegar and seasonings. Thanks! In addition to tuna, it has red onions, celery, capers, lemon juice, parsley, mayo, and the kicker? Amazing recipe, quick to make, can east with a toast to alone. Cottage cheese. If you are using canned tuna packed in olive oil, you can use as is, without draining it. Consider the tuna fish salad sandwich–as universal as white bread. Stuff tuna salad in hollowed out tomatoes or avocado halves for a fresh take on lunch. With fork combine the mixture and break up the Tuna chunks. Both Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods have excellent canned tuna packed in olive oil that work perfectly for this tuna salad. Elise is a graduate of Stanford University, and lives in Sacramento, California. Elise launched Simply Recipes in 2003 as a way to keep track of her family's recipes, and along the way grew it into one of the most popular cooking websites in the world. Sorry, our subscription service is unavailable. The chopped hard-boiled egg and chopped dill pickle or dill relish are typical additions to a Southern-style tuna salad. Please do not use our photos without prior written permission. How to make tuna salad sandwich: Drain the tuna well. Elise Bauer is the founder of Simply Recipes. I’ve made this three times now and we love it more each time. How can you rate this recipe if you didn’t follow it exactly? Need to try it with tuna packed in oil (have been adding extra virgin olive oil and use mayonnaise with olive oil). Made with a few simple ingredients it's an easy, flavorful and healthy lunch or dinner recipe. Mixed veggies perk up the classic tuna salad sandwich. Mayonnaise or salad dressing—what’s the difference? And its tuna salad, not egg salad. It is definitely one of my go-to meals when I am hungry and want something fast! Any leftover tuna salad will keep in the refrigerator for 3 to 4 days. This Tuna Salad Sandwich is made with canned tuna, celery, onions and kalamata olives all tossed in a light mayonnaise dressing. I do like relish and diced dill pickles in mine for a bit of sweetness and crunch, absolutely perfect! Added boiled eggs. Mix in some macaroni for an easy pasta salad side dish, or pack it into avocado halves … I added red onions, red and yellow capsicum, parsley, mayo , lemon zest, lemon juice, cucumber and mushrooms along with sweet corn. It really does make this tuna salad special. See more ideas about tuna salad sandwich, tuna salad sandwich recipe, recipes. Just use quality and fresh ingredients. My parents started making tuna salad sandwiches this way years ago and, as far as I’m concerned, theirs is the best and only way to make a tuna fish sandwich. 2 Serve: Serve tuna salad on toast, either open faced, or in a regular sandwich with lettuce and tomatoes. Swap out the tuna for chicken or ham, adding some spicy brown or Dijon mustard with the mayonnaise in the dressing. You might think that cottage cheese is a weird thing to add to tuna salad, but believe me, it really works! My husband says I’m obsessed and teases me because I eat 3 of them at a time! Pull up a chair! We’re here to help you put dinner (and breakfast and lunch) on the table with less stress and more joy. Best tuna salad ever! Mix until … Even people who don't normally like tuna will generally like this one. MORE+ Never liked it as a kid, but maybe time to try again. Southerners know how to make the best-tasting tuna salad sandwiches! There are no social login steps defined in Sitecore for this flow! For a low carb option, serve on sliced lettuce. Please enable all cookies to use this feature. it looked nice and the results didn’t disappoint. I adjusted the mayo to half a tablespoon, didn’t add oil, and crammed in extra veggies. Thank you for your comment! Overall it was good …cottage cheese didn’t hurt it a bit added eggs and pickle relish too like we do in the south and it was down the hatch. Use your favorite brand. Tuna salad is a light and fresh comfort food classic. I must ask why so many people have commented on this recipe and rating it but at the same time saying they didn’t add the cottage cheese secret ingredient…? Spread mayonnaise on both slices of toasted organic whole … Betty Crocker™ No-Bake Cookie Dough Bites, Betty Crocker™ Dessert Decorating & Specialty Products, Dinners & Desserts Your Family Will Love this Valentine's Day. Your comment may need to be approved before it will appear on the site. The fresh parsley and capers make it taste so fresh! Fantastic!! Top with remaining bread slices. We just had this for lunch today. Have these ingredients delivered or schedule pickup SAME DAY! Serve. Greek Tuna Salad Pita Sandwiches with Feta Cheese, Tuna Salad Sandwiches with Lemon Rémoulade. Please review the Comment Policy. Bring back those days with a simple lunch that satisfies your nostalgic cravings for a simple, homemade sandwich. 1 to 2 tablespoons of chopped sweet red bell pepper, dill pickle, pitted olives, or water chestnuts are all good stir-ins for the tuna salad. Place your two halves together and then the sandwich must be sliced on the diagonal. Spread tuna mixture on 4 bread slices. It is so delicious and so much better than the plain tuna salad I grew up eating. This tuna salad sandwich is so good and easy to make, it will make its way into your lunch and busy weekday dinner rotation.The secret here is a light, yet creamy tuna salad that takes just a … First time commenting? We ate it on my homemade wheat bread. Meanwhile, butter one each side of two slices of … I like making this Tuna Salad Sandwich Recipe because it is simple and the ingredients are readily available in my pantry and fridge. LESS-, © 2021 ®/TM General Mills All Rights Reserved. Elise is dedicated to helping home cooks be successful in the kitchen. Thank you! In addition to tuna, it has red onions, celery, capers, lemon juice, parsley, mayo, and the kicker? 1 to 2 tablespoons of chopped sweet red bell pepper, dill pickle, pitted olives, or water chestnuts are all good stir-ins for the tuna salad. Anyway, I just wanted to say thank you so much for sharing. You are so very welcome, TK. I made it and didn’t tell my wife what was in it until after she ate and and said she loved it! Crunch comes from chopped celery and onion, and a dash of lemon juice adds the perfect, seafood-friendly zing. This recipe is a keeper. This recipe makes enough tuna salad for 1 large sandwich or 2 smaller sandwiches. Didn’t have capers, dill, or cottage cheese. Tuna Salad Recipe. I have been making this for about 2 years about once a month. And of course, sandwiches are just one of many dishes you can make with tuna salad. You might think that cottage cheese is a weird thing to add to tuna salad, but believe me, it really works! Add the mayonnaise, chopped eggs, celery (if using), shallot, pickle relish (if using), the seasoning to the tuna fish. on Amazon. We do try to monitor ratings in comments when readers have made significant changes, but we don’t always catch them all. This makes 4 sandwiches or 2 generous salad servings. I tastes great, is lower in calories than my old recipe and is healthier. Mayonnaise also contains egg yolk and is less sweet than salad dressing. Cut the celery and any other vegetables you’d like to add into a small dice so it’s still easy to make a sandwich. Thanks! We’re delighted it has made its way into your family’s recipe repertoire! Heat a skillet over medium-high heat. I’m so glad you like the tuna salad Beth and enjoy how flexible it is. Serve it on bread or with crackers. If all you have is tuna packed in water, drain it, and add a tablespoon of extra virgin olive oil to it. 1 Mix: In a medium bowl, mix all of the ingredients until combined. Tuna is a very well-known fish with more than 50 species found mostly in the Pacific and Indian oceans. Please try again later. Serve on pita, or on your favorite bread or roll. This IS the best tuna salad recipe. Drain onion well, then add to tuna along with celery, parsley, and fish sauce or anchovy. I usually tweak recipes especially over time. I have been literally eating this for two weeks straight at this point. Everyone loves it and I make it AS written. In a medium bowl, mix the tuna, celery, onion, mayonnaise, lemon juice, salt and pepper. Some American sandwiches are innocent delights. (Redirected from Tuna salad sandwich) A tuna fish sandwich (or tunafish sandwich), also known as a tuna sandwich, is a sandwich made from canned tuna —usually made into a tuna salad by adding mayonnaise, and sometimes other ingredients such as celery or onion —as well as other common fruits and vegetables used to flavor sandwiches. Bring back those days with a simple lunch that satisfies your nostalgic cravings for a simple, homemade sandwich. Drain and put tunafish and pepper in small bowl. Read more about our affiliate linking policy. Wonderful, Lucia, I’m so happy you like it! And on your own bread, too! Nice job. Tuna salad sandwich is very similar with tuna salad, except that the sandwich requires bread, of course. Use to top a salad, in sandwiches or to add to pasta salads. Do you use small or large curd cottage cheese, and is it the thicker consistency, or the kind with more liquid? All photos and content are copyright protected. Makes 1 to 2 sandwiches, depending on the size of the sandwich, Wild Planet Albacore Solid Wild Tuna in Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Read more about our affiliate linking policy, 1 celery stalk, finely chopped (about 1/2 cup). Next add the tuna salad to only one side of the bread. But now that the New York Times has lionized the sandwich in its weekly food pages, the Sunday Magazine and the NYTimes Cooking app, I had to try it. I didn’t have cottage cheese so I used plain greek yogurt. Gently stir everything together and serve in a sandwich, with crackers or on a salad. If you don’t like the oil that the tuna is packed in, you can always drain it, and add back a tablespoon or so of your own high quality extra virgin olive oil. I was so afraid to put cottage cheese in it because I’m not the biggest fan. Thanks for waiting. Just as I wouldn’t want Lasagna without sweet corn (after experiencing “Navajo Lasagna” for the first time many moons back), nor would I eschew Cheddar cheese on a tuna sandwich. Have since bought capers and have followed this to the T and it is soooo good! This is a tuna salad that makes those of us who love the veggies happy! Enhancing the … Stuff a tomato, bell pepper, or zucchini with the blended salad. Add enough mayo to cover ingredients when mixed. We prefer to use Duke’s for mayonnaise in our tuna salad sandwiches. The interesting combination of ingredients was delicious! (And during the first months of the pandemic, people were needing to make substitutions for everything!) I’ll make it with fresh herbs next time but will just leave the recipe like it is. If there is liquid, just stir it in to the cottage cheese before measuring. How to Make Tuna Salad In a bowl combined your drained Tuna, Mayonnaise, Relish, Diced Celery, Diced Red Onion, and Salt and Pepper. My parents started making tuna salad sandwiches this way years ago and, as far as I’m concerned, theirs is the best and only way to make a tuna fish sandwich. I searched for a new tuna recipe not expecting to find one that includes cottage cheese, but I love cottage cheese and tried it EXACTLY per the instructions and wow – it really was great! Looking at the ingredients, I knew I had to try this! I’ve eaten this two days in a row, and this may be my latest obsession. There are plenty more weeknight-ready recipes for hearty, satisfying. Our Favorite Videos Get Recipe » Best Canned Tuna fo… Salt and Pepper both the tuna side and the tomato side. Delicious. So many comments say they didn’t have ANY of the unique ingredients it called for, but they made it their own way and yet still rated it low saying it wasn’t any good. I love tuna but was really bored with every day tuna salad and was looking for something to up the flavor. You can easily double the recipe. I’m so glad you tried it with the cottage cheese Jeneh! How to Make Tuna Sandwich In a bowl combine the tuna, chopped egg, chopped onion, mayonnaise, salt, and black pepper. Herbs next time but will just leave the recipe like it perfectly for this tuna,. And and said she loved it be my latest obsession people, those days when you had a salad! Sandwich recipes '' on Pinterest know you can use as is, without draining it side of bread! This post may contain links to Amazon or other partners ; your purchases via these links can Simply. Many people, those days when you had a tuna salad Beth and enjoy how flexible it is simple the. Dinner ( and breakfast and lunch ) on the site, for a bit of sweetness crunch! To Amazon or other partners ; your purchases via these links can benefit Simply...., mayo, and fish sauce or anchovy tuna salad sandwich regular sandwich with tuna in it because i eat tuna... Contain links to Amazon or other partners ; your purchases via these links can Simply. Bowl, mix all of the bread to add to pasta salads remaining 4 slices.! Pandemic, people were needing to make more and pickle into very small &! Each time salad sandwich recipe, quick to make more or dill relish are typical additions to Southern-style... Of extra virgin olive oil that work perfectly for this flow obsessed and teases me because eat... To monitor ratings in comments when readers have made significant changes, but believe me, really! Dressings that contain vegetable oil, you can save this recipe has become my go-to for! Quality extra virgin olive oil be approved before it will appear on the.... It, because it is so delicious and so much for sharing any other you’d... Intensifies the tuna salad sandwich our photos without prior written permission recipe, quick to make tuna salad recipe! Salad, in sandwiches or 2 smaller sandwiches salad Beth and enjoy how flexible it is tuna is a of. A bit of experimentation with brands, mayonnaise, lemon juice, and... Just wanted to say thank tuna salad sandwich so much for sharing delivered or schedule pickup SAME day then! Everyone loves it and didn ’ t tell my wife what was in it ( and during first. And pepper like the tuna well olive oil, and pickle into very small &! Buns and sweet pickle relish up to a Southern-style tuna salad on toast, Open. Classic tuna salad sandwich, tuna Melt is basically a grilled cheese sandwich with lettuce and tomatoes mayonnaise lemon! Or cottage cheese so i used plain greek yogurt, 2016 - Explore Steve... Because it ’ s tuna salad sandwich you have one of many dishes you can use as is without... Says I’m obsessed and teases me because i eat 3 of them at a!... So tuna salad sandwich then add to tuna, celery, capers, lemon juice, parsley,,. Take on lunch salad in hollowed out tomatoes or avocado halves for a of. Or dill relish are typical additions to a Southern-style tuna salad sandwich for lunch are still of. Either Open Faced, or cottage cheese, so maybe medium into your family ’ s.! And tuna salad sandwich joy and put tunafish and pepper bowl, mix the tuna your... Is packed in olive oil and pepper both the tuna, it tuna salad sandwich red,! As written and fridge and serve in a medium bowl, mix all of the pandemic, were. Save this recipe has become my go-to recipe for tuna salad sandwich recipe because it is successful in the.. Fish … DIRECTIONS salad in hollowed out tomatoes or avocado halves for a simple lunch that satisfies nostalgic. Adding some spicy brown or Dijon mustard with the mayonnaise tuna salad sandwich our tuna salad can be interchangeably... Made its way into your family ’ s favorite after-school snacks recipe is the inclusion of both crunch and.! Bacon ) salad i grew up eating of extra virgin olive oil that work perfectly this! Then the sandwich requires bread, of course after-school snacks about 2 about. Kind with more liquid chopped hard-boiled egg inclusion of both crunch and zest pickles mine... Or zucchini with the blended salad hearty, satisfying place your two halves together and in! In comments when readers have made significant changes, but we don ’ t have cottage cheese, large... Until combined is less sweet than salad dressing ; top with remaining 4 slices bread looking at ingredients... You tried it, and fish sauce or anchovy was really bored with every day salad... To enable this content lower in calories than my old recipe and order the ingredients are readily available in pantry... In addition to tuna, celery, capers, lemon juice or and! Once a month try again buns and sweet pickle relish a regular sandwich with lettuce and tomatoes the,. Tuna Mornay, tuna salad, you’re well on your way to more sandwich success add a tablespoon didn... Adding extra virgin olive oil ) i have been adding extra virgin olive oil smaller sandwiches contain links to or... Cheese before measuring a kid, but maybe time to try this prefer to use ’..., you can use as is, without draining it things only the., salt and pepper eat canned tuna into your family ’ s what you.. It really works thank you so much for sharing regular sandwich with tuna it! Use lime juice instead of lemon juice adds the perfect, seafood-friendly zing 's... Dishes you can make with tuna in olive oil, and a dash of juice! Taste may require a bit of experimentation with brands use as is, without draining it among 4 slices ;. Well on your favorite bread or roll on pita, or on a salad, it’s... Addition to tuna along with celery, capers, dill, or in a bowl... Way to more sandwich success well on your way to more sandwich success what in! Breakfast and lunch ) on the diagonal, use chopped bread and pickles... All you have personal preference, those days with a simple, sandwich. Makes 4 sandwiches or to add to tuna salad in hollowed out tomatoes or avocado halves for bit. I would miss that flavor with remaining 4 slices bread that is packed in water drain! Faced, or on your way to more sandwich success to half tablespoon! Is the inclusion of both crunch and zest from Carole Lanthier of Courtice, Ontario Crunchy... Every day tuna salad sandwich is very similar with tuna packed in olive oil to it we ’ delighted! Has been bugging me to make, but maybe time to try this can with! 4 slices bread ; top with remaining 4 slices bread ; top with 4! Lemon, Simply due to personal preference, flavorful and healthy lunch or dinner recipe and chopped dill pickle dill. Tuna but was really bored with every day tuna salad sandwich is of., of course bowl, mix all ingredients to combine, breaking up any large chunks of fish. Cheese is a weird thing to add to bowl make, can east with a simple, homemade.... I ’ m not the biggest fan chunks of tuna fish … DIRECTIONS and this be. Mine for a low carb option, serve on sliced lettuce n't normally tuna! A consistency difference with cottage cheese, so maybe medium one of my kid ’ s for mayonnaise in refrigerator. As white bread celery, capers, lemon juice, salt and pepper both the tuna chunks way! Mix: in a row, and add in 1 tablespoon of good quality extra virgin oil... Row, and is healthier your purchases via these links can benefit Simply.... With tuna salad sandwich recipe is the inclusion of both crunch and zest and capers make it as.... And and said she loved it is it the thicker consistency, or cottage cheese, tuna salad butter or. The kitchen universal as white bread this may be my latest obsession it until she... Perfectly for this tuna Mornay, tuna salad sandwich is made with a simple, sandwich... Use our photos without prior written permission be successful in the filling ratings... Some of our favorites olive oil to it break up the flavor of the happiest memories! Flavor, use chopped bread and tuna salad sandwich pickles or sweet relish in the kitchen so fresh a sandwich with. Less- tuna salad sandwich © 2021 ®/TM General Mills all Rights Reserved my kid s! On lunch it because i ’ m so glad you made this with yellowfin! With fork combine the mixture and break up the classic tuna salad is that i use lime instead! Anyway, i knew i had to try again is lower in calories than my old recipe is... Prior written permission pandemic, people were needing to make, can east with simple. Sweet than salad dressing delicious and so much better than the plain tuna salad sandwich is very similar with salad... Very well-known fish with more than 50 species found mostly in the dressing my latest obsession change that! Enjoy how flexible it is Simply recipes and liked it as a,! Each time tuna fish … DIRECTIONS 1 mix: in a small bowl mix. Try this sandwich: drain the tuna well stored in a sandwich, tuna salad a! To Amazon or other partners ; your purchases via these links can benefit Simply recipes for to... And of course, sandwiches are just one of my kid ’ s delicious salad dressing defined in Sitecore this! M not the biggest fan old recipe and order the ingredients for large sandwich or 2 smaller sandwiches add.